Archaeologists find possible first direct evidence of Hannibal's war elephants (smithsonianmag.com)

62 points by bryanrasmussen 4 hours ago

HelloUsername 3 hours ago

Related: "Single bone in Spain offers first direct evidence of Hannibal's war elephants" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46917005 06-feb-2026 40 comments

shevy-java 2 hours ago

> A second-century Roman mosaic of a war elephant in Tunisia

It is quite interesting to see that the depicted elephant has wrong proportions. This makes one wonder whether the artist who created that mosaic, ever saw an elephant himself.

sonofhans an hour ago

Pure speculation, of course, but I would say so. The hump in the back; the small, high, tail; dominant forehead — those are all things missed by people who mis-draw elephants. I think this artist got them right, which is hard to do from description alone.

bertil an hour ago

I’m very tempted to agree with you: people who draw from description draw unicorns after being told about rhinoceroses. We have a lot of medieval monks’ drawings of elephants by description and theirs look like tapir with a trumpet stuck in their nose. This is not a photo, of course but it mainly highlights the head, like any one would if they didn’t measured proportions carefully.

beloch an hour ago

There has also been debate about which species of elephant Hannibal's forces used. Elsewhere, Hellenistic Greek forces used Asian elephants, but many believe Hannibal used North African elephants, a sub-species that was extirpated by the Romans. Their proportions might have been a little different than living elephants. It will be interesting to see if the bone can help settle this debate.

drekipus 2 hours ago

Wrong to elephants today

inglor_cz an hour ago

Might be a limitation of the medium. Mosaics are complicated.

This famous "skeleton" mosaic has the proportions wrong as well, even though the artist almost certainly saw some actual human skeletons, and definitely some living humans with their longer arms and smaller heads than depicted :)

https://www.thehistoryblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Ha...

__alexander 2 hours ago

Everyone should visit Córdoba, Spain once in their life.

rrr_oh_man an hour ago

why?

inglor_cz an hour ago

The mosque-turned-cathedral is an interesting (and huge) piece of medieval architecture.

The Roman bridge is fascinating as well.

Plus, if you arrive in summer, you will learn what heat is. Córdoba is hot even for the standards of Spanish summers. Hence, interesting night life. Not just drunkards, normal families and everyone who barely survived the day and now has the opportunity to live and socialize outside.

bryanrasmussen 4 hours ago

original title: Archaeologists Unearthed a 2,200-Year-Old Bone. They Say It Could Be the First Direct Evidence of Hannibal’s Legendary War Elephants

sickofparadox 3 hours ago

At this rate, we're only a few years away from discovering evidence for Herodotus' giant ants.

Telemakhos 36 minutes ago

shakna 3 hours ago

Peissel claimed that was marmots and totally real, didn't they?