Hacker News

And interceptors are more expensive than Shaheds. A $100k interceptor (guessing here) to shoot a $10k Shahed can be an acceptable deal for the side launching the Shaheds.

> It's about danger of interceptors vs danger of detection.

What's with that "vs" trade-off?

You're saying avoiding detection requires high altitudes.

What do interceptors have to do with that?

Or an image detection model. Fraction of the compute and can run even on edge embedded. And easy to train with your own data

Clouds and nighttime are a barrier to visual detection. Even with good effectiveness the conditions needed for that would mean that you have far less than 50% uptime, and your downtime is predictable to your adversary.

A cheap radar takes an order of magnitude less power to run on hardware that is cheaper than an LLM and can see way farther than a camera.

The Sensirion SDP600-25Pa speaks I2C and only has a handful of primitive commands. Add this and 3.3V and you are done.

I'm 99.5% sure if you throw Claude with a datasheet on it will Slop out working code for a ESP32 with ESP-IDF.

I’ve always dreamt of building a mesh network of loud vehicle detectors that would map current loud noises and track where loud vehicles live, coupled with very powerful parametric speakers. So when e.g. the network detects a loud motorcycle at 3am anywhere in town, that live sound is instantly played at high volumes targeting only homes where other loud vehicles live.

Somehow there has been little VC interest in this idea.

https://freesound.org/people/PicassoCT/sounds/850225/

Curmudgeon Ai?

Honestly: don't know.

My experiments never had a dependency on linearity.

Not much circuits needed.

The SDP600-25Pa speaks I2C and only has a handful of commands.

Just read it out with a microcontroller you love (like ESP32) and send the samples to a host for analysis. The ESP32 has limited I2C time stretching capabilities limiting it in the highest resolution modes of the sensor - but often that's not a big factor.

To not overwhelm the poor processor and Wifi maybe better a bunch of frames (like 512 or more).

Theoretically wind can be Nulled with a 4-way water splitter that are placed in 90° angles (+ a connector at the bottom to the sensor). As long they are orthogonal the wind pressure coming from one side will cause a negative pressure on the opposite.

Only pressure waves coming into all holes at the same time will reach sensor.

Never tested it. Only a Gedankenexperiment as Einstein would say.

Yes. But they usually are not performing very good between 1-250Hz.

Sensirion is using a thermal flow-sensing principle method which is basically a heated plate that cools/heats up when air passes it - making it extremely sensitive in this range.

> Defense capabilities and straight up cost and looks to be that way for a good while.

You are correct, that today, we (USA) lack the capability to defend against this threat in a meaningful way.

> Multi billion dollar spend to “see” $2,000 aircraft

Look at how we deploy SOCOM assets today: smaller teams in the field far from fixed detection, a satellite to do this job, allows it to be tasked rather than having to deploy more, fixed detection equipment.

As part of a larger system it would be integrated by software: see the "Lattice" project from Anduril.

> and try to shoot it down with multi million dollar equipment.

DAWG, (Defense Autonomous Warfare Group ) has requested a billion dollar base budget and 54 billion of flexible spending (More than the USMC per year) for 2027.

There is also the "Replicator" program (I think headed for phase two) to get unit costs back down, and volume up. Facets of this are bleeding into other spend. Andurill openly talks about unit costs, and how few tools are needed to put together their low cost missiles (still more expensive than drones but... headed in the right direction).

As for the astronomical size of that budget: it's cheap to build an idea, what is hard is testing. The Ukrainians have a massive advantage here, in that they ship these things to the front line. It's much cheaper to trial things when you don't have to buy something to blow up, repeatedly.

The US military has been falling behind for 25 years now (especially the navy: if you want to understand why it has become schrodinger's straight read this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002 ) and I think what is going on in Ukraine has been eye opening for them.

Apples != oranges

How is Elon evil?