A Perfect SimCity (jeffquast.com)
203 points by mariuz 4 days ago
_whiteCaps_ 3 hours ago
A SimCity fact I love to share:
https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/05/the-p...
> Geoff Manaugh: While you were making those measurements of different real-world cities, did you discover any surprising patterns or spatial relationships?
> Librande: Yes, definitely. I think the biggest one was the parking lots. When I started measuring out our local grocery store, which I don't think of as being that big, I was blown away by how much more space was parking lot rather than actual store. That was kind of a problem, because we were originally just going to model real cities, but we quickly realized there were way too many parking lots in the real world and that our game was going to be really boring if it was proportional in terms of parking lots.
hnlmorg 2 hours ago
This is something that surprised me the first time I came to America. In the UK, local shops have much less parking because the assumption is local residents will generally walk there. And in city centres, most people use public transport anyway.
But in America it was generally expected that people would drive everywhere. So much space was taken up by parking lots.
munk-a 2 hours ago
And people end up needing to drive in America because the parking lots make buildings so far apart thus feeding back into the same problem. It has impacted the US in a deeply negative manner.
stronglikedan 2 hours ago
lkbm 2 hours ago
They still tend to be way oversized for everyone driving. Some of this is zoning requirements -- banks have to have parking lots sized for the size of the bank, even though their traffic volume is tiny.
But even grocery stores where almost everyone does drive. I'm not sure I've ever seen a full parking lot at any supermarket or big box store. Maybe I need to stop by Costco on Black Friday.
schindlabua 2 hours ago
readthenotes1 an hour ago
People in the United States regularly fill up SUVs and vans with groceries. Walking is just not an option when you're buying so much.
(Counter argument: throw out all the food-like substances from the purchase and maybe you could actually carry the groceries easily...)
hnlmorg an hour ago
lostapathy an hour ago
mock-possum 2 hours ago
You’re expected to walk or use public transit to the groccery store to buy a weeks worth of grocceries for a family of 4? Does everyone pull wagons around?
stronglikedan 2 hours ago
esikich an hour ago
zapkyeskrill 2 hours ago
stavros 10 minutes ago
justsomehnguy an hour ago
Someone 2 hours ago
> we quickly realized there were way too many parking lots in the real world
https://www.fastcompany.com/90645900/america-has-eight-parki...:
“Parking standards were created arbitrarily, without adequate data. Zoning laws usually require one parking space per apartment, one per 300 square feet of commercial development, and one per 100 square feet for restaurants. For context, a parking space measures 160 square feet on average, plus additional area for driveways and driving lanes, so an eatery’s parking lot may be three times the size of its dining area.”
phaser 5 hours ago
I love SimCity, but after a few hundred hours of playing (or at least the early ones) you can't ignore the fact that in order to build the "optimal" city you would need to create the counterintuitive things that are described here, like cities that are rail-only. Or the "perfect" rate of death by starving.
I often wonder if that's also an unintentional reflection coming from simulating real life, where there's sadly too many examples of people with enough power to attempt a "optimisation" that regards human life as purely a math game.
In the 1980s, Dictator Augusto Pinochet was questioned about missing persons by a journalist who points out coffins have been found with two, or three bodies in it, as to what he responds "What a great cost-saving!" [1]
Maybe half of the countries in the world had had an "optimiser" who was playing the SimCity score hacking with economic and social shocks that chase some sort of equilibrium for the "greater good" and just like in SimCity[2] the process leaned towards a dehumanising dystopia.
Maybe we have a group of "world-optimisers" running a country right now? Perhaps a big one?
While working on my own city builder [3] I've had the fortune to travel a lot to learn about what makes cities great, and my favourite cities are far from perfect, my personal feeling is that in a lot of aspects is quite the opposite: chaos, diversity, entropy, is what's intuitive about cities where people look free and happy, not order and perfect numbers.
1. https://es.wikiquote.org/wiki/Augusto_Pinochet
2. https://www.moma.org/interactives/exhibitions/2013/designand...
Waterluvian 4 hours ago
I think optimizing a game (much like a speedrun) is a very different mode of play entirely. It's an acceptance of not playing the game the way it was designed.
What I've noticed is that the more a city builder is optimized, the more you're engaging with the hidden systems and not the whole game itself. You're not laying out a city because it makes sense, you're placing things because you've essentially reverse engineered the code and know exactly how many police stations you need and stuff like that.
jader201 2 hours ago
Except the whole point — or at least arguably the biggest point — of SimCity is optimization.
Most speedran games aren’t designed for speedrunning. But people do it anyway. The goal by design in many of these games is to simply beat the game, with a secondary goal of completing any side quests (e.g. 100%-ing the game).
Speedrunning is often not a goal of the designers (though most know it will be a goal for some players).
SimCity asks to be optimized. You want your city to flourish, which means finding ways to optimize your design.
Yes, this often means a more realistic design, and yes at some point that optimization crosses into counterintuitive designs. But that’s a line the player must draw, as it’s not always super clear, especially for people that don’t fully know what a realistic optimal city design looks like.
Waterluvian an hour ago
JLO64 29 minutes ago
I just took a look at your game and I love how you can purchase a DRM free version of the game for Linux! That said, have you considered putting your game on GOG? (I personally prefer that platform).
mangogogo 10 minutes ago
Great writeup and great-looking game, just got it on itch.io with the current 60% discount. Excited to play it tonight!
achairapart 3 hours ago
Just wanted to say thank you for Microlandia! I enjoy playing with it from time to time. While it's still not perfect (or maybe I can't fully grasp all of its economy rules) I always look forward for new updates, I hope develoment will continue steadly.
eek2121 3 hours ago
I seem remember that on the SNES version, the right move was to not use roads at all and create donuts of zones with a park, police station, fire station, etc. in the middle. It was totally counter-intuitive at the time, but it was the most scalable design at the time.
tecleandor 3 hours ago
Aw! I've got your game in my library but I haven't had time to start. Can be played casually or do you have to dedicate time to it?
phaser 2 hours ago
Casually is actually fine. Thanks!
mrguyorama an hour ago
Early game cash flow management can be tricky, but once you get to a minimum city size that can support itself, you get immense financial freedom to construct whatever city you want.
Luck with an election gift can make or break you.
It's weirdly fun to be running by the skin of your teeth, a few months away from insolvency, juggling loans. Eventually though you will have far more money than you know what to do with.
The game still seems to be seeing significant development and change though. I bought it before electricity was meaningful and thought it was fun then!
smolder 4 hours ago
I think the evidence is in that people with history-changing levels of influence, in recent history, typically see people as numbers. Numbers in service of their absurd wealth, which has no practical purpose. You can only buy so many yachts, and building megayachts is stupid to start with. The best rich people in history realized the power of their wealth and had grand designs. Not "let's move to mars", but "let's make human life better and longer lasting".
Aunche 2 hours ago
> Maybe we have a group of "world-optimisers" running a country right now?
I wish. Singapore does this (the good and the bad parts), but basically every other country is run off of vibes. The land value tax is almost universally regardless by economists as the most efficient tax, but it's barely implemented anywhere.
Centigonal 3 hours ago
> Maybe we have a group of "world-optimisers" running a country right now? Perhaps a big one?
Well, the person who created worldoptimization.tumblr.com certainly tried!
stevetron 3 hours ago
Two bodies in a coffin as cost-savings? Building on this approach, something even better is from the Fantasm-series of movies, where the Tall-man is a grave robber who re-animates the dead and turns them into a slave workforce on another planet. Thus the graves are always empty, no matter how many bodies you put in them.
alfiedotwtf 4 hours ago
> can't ignore the fact that in order to build the "optimal" city you would need to create the counterintuitive things that are described here, like…
… increasing unemployment just to keep inflation down. Oh, sorry wait, that’s real life
manoDev 3 hours ago
This hasn't been working anymore since the 70-80's, though. People don't have stable jobs like their grandpas anymore, many people are self-employed.
That's why a lot of countries are struggling to fight inflation post-COVID.
ninalanyon 2 hours ago
matwood 4 hours ago
Except that's not counterintuitive. People just don't like to talk about it. Fighting inflation means also fighting rising wages since they are also inflating.
benrutter 4 hours ago
tristor 3 hours ago
benrutter 4 hours ago
... or reducing social welfare and increasing environmental destruction to boost GDP. Oh nope, did the same thing!
cavemandaveman 3 hours ago
rexpop 3 hours ago
Pinochet was being facetious.
theflyingelvis 5 hours ago
Mabel Addis creator of The Sumerian Game
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/08/24/obituaries/mabel-addis-ov...
schnevets 4 hours ago
It's funny seeing someone else comment on that concluding snippet of the larger article. I had no idea about her legacy and have just gone down a half-hour rabbit hole learning more about this game.
theflyingelvis 2 hours ago
Yeah. I did the same.
lubujackson 3 hours ago
Another one of those "women get no recognition" casualties. Reminds me of the person who wrote the first novel, a Japanese noblewoman who wrote The Tale of Genji.
monster_truck 7 hours ago
Great post.
I have really fond childhood memories of learning every aspect of sc2k by reading through "SimCity 2000 - Power, Politics, And Planning, Revised Edition", actually figuring out how to build a city that would flourish was so rewarding.
shevy-java 5 hours ago
I always tried it with trial and error first.
Back then I kind of had a routine to build up a commercial area and then living areas next to them. First I had to connect the nuclear plants to them though ...
SimAnts was also cool - a bit too simple, but it had many great ideas. Such games would be perfect for learning things too, that is for kids - e. g. extend the biology aspect of it.
ryandrake 3 hours ago
I loved SimAnt. Always wanted to build a modern clone of it. One great gameplay element was that as you moved on in the game, you’d go from navigating an individual ant to leading a swarm of ants, then the game shifts to be more strategy where you are manually managing which “tiles” to occupy next. Finally, you often end up adjusting the worker/fighter/breeder ratios and don’t even control ants anymore, as you go into the end game.
THansenite 2 hours ago
t_e_s 5 hours ago
This approach of reimplementing a game to understand it (in another post by author https://www.jeffquast.com/post/hamurabi_bas/) has been something I've really been enjoying recently.
I made a fantasy mobile variant of Mechabellum and smashed a lot of Chesterton's fences in the process - very educational.
solarexplorer 5 hours ago
Same here. I got to appreciate pacman a lot more!
waltbosz 6 hours ago
The Super Nintendo version of Simcity was so much fun. I stayed up too late playing it many nights in my childhood. I was never great at it, figuring out the rules of simulation games didn't interest me, but I still had fun.
mathgeek 6 hours ago
Something I really enjoyed was moving between the PC and SNES versions. Each had their charm and it was fun to "change the rules" now and then.
nico 3 hours ago
Very interesting. Related, but on a tangent. Someone used something like REA to make a simcity 2k clone that runs on the browser and can load the original sc2 city files
maurits 5 hours ago
Reminds me of simcity 3000 its legendary hellish Magnasanti [1]
PowerElectronix 3 hours ago
That's what happens when you take a top-down approach to a bottom-up problem. People want to live in societies in order to live better lives. Being the manager of a big society and optimizing it, instead of the lives of the people, is what causes this degenerate strategies to win.
The man that wields the streadsheet sees everyone as a number.
lifefeed 2 hours ago
I can't believe I remember this, but the land used for bigcity5 was my favorite land. I'd always build the mayors house on that island in the river.
thomasfl 2 hours ago
More people should be involved in how real cities are planned and built. If only people working as developers in private real estate companies decides what to build, then that will eventually result in very bad places for everybody. Four years ago I started an NGO in Norway called the Architectural uprising. The real estate market and building industry is one giant clusterf*ck in Norway. It costs around 70% more to build housing here than across the border in Sweden. Tax cuts for people with great mortgage on their homes, have created a real estate bubble that sooner or later is going to burst. We simply don't get more of the types of cities needed for local businesses to grow, for people to spend less time wasting time stuck in traffic in private cars and places suited to raise kids. There's much more important, and frankly interesting, stuff to do than playing SimCity.
dfxm12 5 hours ago
I like that SC2K eschewed the scoring. The score is easy enough to ignore in SC, but its mere presence suggests that there is some specific way to win or lose. That SC2K doesn't even present a score suggests that the game is open ended and operates more on your terms.
philistine 4 hours ago
Sim City 2K is a game made by people who understood what people were enjoying from Sim City.
ndiddy 3 hours ago
IIRC part of that was because Maxis were having a hard time getting publishers to understand that people would want to play a game with no win/lose state or scoring. The scenarios were another concession to this.
manoDev 3 hours ago
Looking at what is "optimal" makes it clear SimCity is just a game, and doesn't really attempt to model reality.
I wonder if realistic simulations have been attempted?
NuclearPM 3 hours ago
Modeling reality on a 286 computer is hard. It was an attempt and it was wonderful.
mock-possum 2 hours ago
For reference, what’s an example of an optimal city in reality?
hizlikovboy27 5 hours ago
This reminds me of the Atari games I used to play in my childhood. I would spend hours playing them.
elfly 4 hours ago
find weird that nobody has ported the snes extras to micropolis
robotmay 5 hours ago
I went through a period of trying to "solve" traffic in Cities: Skylines a few years back. Ultimately I succeeded; by making the entire city a one-way spiral into the centre, where a bridge then took drivers back out to the start. It was perfect.
Later I decided to travel on-board with a citizen and realised that this was a form of torture, turning slightly left for around an hour. Want to go to a shop one block in the wrong direction? Tough shit - into the hell spiral.
Could be worse though, I could have modelled it on Oxford.
fishtoaster 34 minutes ago
I went through a similar exercise a few years back as part of my goal to hit the population cap of 1m in the base game. I tried building a city on a hilbert curve road, but straight-line pathing for service vehicles killed me.
I eventually landed on a series of isolated, "entry only" pods of well-balanced RCI (residential, commercial, industrial). Each pod had a one-way highway entrance to allow entry for industrial goods and initial move-in and no way out. My residents were going to live and die in their 15-minutes cities, goddamnit! :)
It turned out pretty dystopian as well.
Edit: found my old writeup on that - https://www.reddit.com/r/CitiesSkylines/comments/13c5hu8/yet...
jandrese 23 minutes ago
Yet another person who falls victim to the siren song of the Traffic Circle in Cities: Skylines. I have to be impressed at the dedication of turning your city into one giant traffic spiral with almost no exits.
That said, it seems like it should have been possible to make the roads two way, your big advantage was the lack of intersections. Also, this concept probably works pretty well in Cities: Skylines if you put walkways between the buildings. Cims can drive to the correct clock position and park, sticking the car in their pocket, and then walk directly inward to their destination.
sandworm101 5 hours ago
I think the Saudis were playing Skylines when they came up with "The Line", a linear city following one transportation route. But at least The Line would have allowed travel in either direction, only a half-torture.
bovermyer 6 hours ago
In my games of SimCity, the best cities were the ones that were on fire, exploding, stomped by not-Godzilla, or otherwise having a _very challenging day._
peri-cl 4 hours ago
> "not-Godzilla"
I literally just learned about that Maxis history a few days ago. Here's Don Hopkins quoting Jeff Braun's account of it,
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40050799#:~:text=We%20a... ("We paid $50k for Godzilla to go away")
octocop 6 hours ago
> what improves a city most is reducing available housing
So that is why housing is so expensive in cities
dsr_ 5 hours ago
Every measurable proxy for your actual goal that becomes a target will be gamed, and thus becomes useless.
In the real world, housing in cities should be more expensive than in the surrounding suburbs, which should be more expensive than the rural areas, because the higher-paying jobs in those denser areas should compensate for that. In return, city dwellers should get a higher quality, availability and affordability of services because they are more efficient to provide in the denser areas.
This doesn't actually happen, because housing policy and tax policy are broken in most areas.
afavour 4 hours ago
In that ideal scenario, where do the lower paid workers who work in the city live? e.g. is a Starbucks barista commuting into the city for 45 minutes? Those workers are required for the higher-paying folks to enjoy their life in the city so making _all_ city housing expensive could be counter productive.
thesuitonym 4 hours ago
wat10000 3 hours ago
The relative desirability of cities would push housing prices up. But the efficiency of cities should push prices down. It's not clear to me which one should be more significant. Cities do seem to be more expensive in reality, but how much of that is desirability beating efficiency, and how much is artificial supply constraints?
Kuyawa 4 hours ago
"I found the best strategy is systemic starvation of 3% of the population"
WTF? I know politicians love this way of thinking but didn't know computer simulations would agree with them
snkline 3 hours ago
Have you tried "Kill all the poor"?
zhengyi13 36 minutes ago
It's just a modest proposal!
feliksgorisek23 4 hours ago
I love SimCity. Back to the childhood again. :)
mock-possum 2 hours ago
> When the number of jobs exceeds the residents zoned to fill them, The Unemployment term goes negative and adds to the score, providing a score bonus of about 128 points. No other term moves the score this much.
Interesting exploit!
teiferer 2 hours ago
Sounds like a perfect task for an AI agent. Give them the source code, let them figure out what approach would maximize that metric, then let them play it. Alternatively, don't even give them the source code, just let them so trial and error.
Could even turn into a LLM benchmark of sorts.
TMWNN 2 hours ago
I have long thought that all politicians should be required to play the original SimCity, Civilization, and M.U.L.E..
TheRealPomax 3 hours ago
But why is the scroll-wheel behaviour for the graphics not respecting the fact that I'm on a desktop with boring old school normal mouse wheel behaviour, zooming the exact opposite from what it should be doing?
xXSLAYERXx 4 hours ago
"skyway one reporting heavy traffic"
shevy-java 5 hours ago
SimCity 1 was a great game. A shame that such games today have no real way to be made, save for some indie games.
ido 5 hours ago
What do you mean "save for some indie games"? There are way more indie games released every year today (and dare I say of higher quality) than there were games in total released in the year the first SimCity did (1989).
oneeyedpigeon 4 hours ago
Without a doubt. There are roughly more games released every week now than were released in the whole of 1989. Soon, I expect that to be every day.
FinnLobsien 5 hours ago
I think a lot of it is that you couldn't rely on graphics back in the day. You had to rely on game design (not visual design, the game dynamics, rewards, scoring, etc.) because stimulating players with constant explosions wasn't an option.
I would disagree that there's no way for these to be made. While somewhat different, games like Slay the Spire and Balatro are incredible games made by 1-2 people.
If anything, it's easier than ever. It's just that the big publishers don't, so these games that are simple on the surface but reveal surprising depth stay in niches.
wtch98 5 hours ago
Sim City 1 was effectively an indie game. Many great games from that era were just built by one or two people - Will Wright, Sid Meier, Chris Sawyer etc. Larger companies may have had half a dozen employees doing everything from marketing to the actual work. I think Grand Theft Auto was built by about 5 people.
wat10000 3 hours ago
Why couldn't it be made today? The original was built by one guy. One guy could build something similar today. And it would be so much easier to actually sell it today. SimCity took ages to find a publisher willing to take it on because it was so unconventional. These days you can just toss it up on Steam.
Steve16384 5 hours ago
"no real way to be made"?
tambourine_man 5 hours ago
Now I’m singing its tune in my head