Comcast's "fiber-powered Wi-Fi" is cable, AT&T says in false advertising case (arstechnica.com)
72 points by jaredwiener 3 hours ago
ben1040 2 hours ago
Back in the days of rolling out U-Verse (their FTTN service), AT&T's advertising used exactly the same strategy of weasel-words to say "fiber" without making an actionable implication that it was fiber from A to Z. Phrases like "fiber rich network" and "U-Verse uses fiber optic technology."
soupfordummies an hour ago
Just a few years ago during the industry-wide upgrades to 5G, AT&T branded their 4G service as "5G E (5G Evolution)"
They are terribly slimy.
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/att-to-drop-misleading-...
altairprime an hour ago
This would make a lovely amicus curiae, if someone were to raise such, on Comcast’s behalf. Not that I think it’s worth the time — they can both rot as far as I’m concerned — but if you want to see AT&T get a bit of fuck around find out energy in a federal lawsuit, a judge would probably quite value an expert opinion prepared to federal court standards. I could very well see them ruling that the lowest-provisioned segment of delivery between the CO and the terminal must be the transport method and capacity advertised, so that they can’t just run FTTH from an ISDN line or call a radio tower gigabit when they only allocate 100mbps to it upstream, and then awarding $1.00 in damages to AT&T (without legal costs) so that both companies are forced to advertise more genuinely, eat their own legal costs for the fight, and so on. It would punish them both for being shitty and provide a foothold into future lawsuits over intentional underprovisioning for after-dinner radio hour. One can dream, sigh.
0cf8612b2e1e an hour ago
Consumer protection via companies calling out their competitors for lies.
I wish there were more effective options in play, but this could be a positive outcome, up until they all agree to stop directly attacking each other.
segmondy 41 minutes ago
TMobile of all companies started offering fiber in my area. They ran fiber lines into the house. Real fiber too, I saw the install. 1000Mbps up/down. I hate Comcast & AT&T. TMobile for now can have all my money. So check your area if you are wanting to get one.
bri3d 9 minutes ago
T-Mobile Fiber is almost always rebrands of local sub-carriers which T-Mobile either acquired or partner with - for example, in my area, they're the anchor tenant for Intrepid Fiber Networks. It's an interesting business model vs. a lot of the competitor models (either owned FTTP or fake-fiber like Comcast and old CenturyLink marketing)
bityard 25 minutes ago
AT&T and T-Mobile both installed fiber in my neighborhood this summer. AT&T started in the spring and still are not done. (Also their workers took out my cable internet with a shovel.)
T-Mobile had my street done in three weeks. They are offering twice the speed and half the price of my current plan through Comcast. I need to remember to call them tomrrow.
lotsofpulp 20 minutes ago
I am amazed you had two different fiber optic lines installed all the way to your home, in addition to coaxial cable. I only ever see fiber in new developments, and if there is buried coaxial cable in an old development, I have never seen it get fiber.
trevithick 3 hours ago
The advertising in this space is terrible. I constantly see ads for "gig wifi" and similar terms and have no idea what the actual internet connection type is.
mixdup 3 hours ago
It's not just advertising, people these days think they are buying "wifi" not internet access. I don't know if it's because of the push of ISPs into being your home network too, or if they got into pushing their wifi and routers so that they can "own" the whole experience but if you go ask the average person on the street what they buy from Xfinity the'll tell you wifi and not internet service
rolph 2 hours ago
how many people have devices with an RJ45 jack, im not sure but it has been diminishing, take that along with the trend to put evrything on 'wifi", and there it is a general training to think internet comes off a wireless feed, to go along with the browser/app is the internet mentality.
pkulak 2 hours ago
I would guess they sell "wifi" because selling someone only a modem (or just the connection) is putting your company on a fast track to death by support costs. Get your techs to drill a single cable through the closest exterior wall, jam it into some all-in-one device, tell the user their new wifi creds, and leave. Easy peasy.
crote 2 hours ago
xp84 2 hours ago
xp84 an hour ago
I kind of feel like this happened by accident and we have companies like Linksys and Netgear to blame. 20 years ago (and I assume still now based on one recent experience) they put out such absolutely garbage hardware, which constantly needs to be rebooted, and which never provided good visibility for the common person to understand the difference between an outage and configuration error. So people eagerly adopted rental routers since they came with the promise that at least Comcast couldn’t just tell you to keep rebooting your computer when you called to report an apparent outage.
And just like that people went from seeing Wi-Fi as a product they were responsible for selecting and maintaining, to one that they expect to subscribe to as a service. And their kids were just raised in that world so Gen-Z definitely “pays their Wi-Fi bill” (eyeroll).
O3marchnative 2 hours ago
Or they say it's a gig, but it's actually only 1G download and something significantly less than 1G for upload.
roosterIllusi0n 2 hours ago
Comcast is the worst for this. Actual fiber companies are selling symmetric connections. Comcast still sells garbage like 1000gbps/30mbps. That is barely enough return bandwidth for traffic overhead.
adgjlsfhk1 2 hours ago
strbean an hour ago
soupfordummies an hour ago
gig is short for "gig work" not "gig-abit"!
/s
bdcravens 2 hours ago
The comparison charts for the services tend to be pretty dishonest, making ridiculous claims about what service you need to support basic vanilla levels of Internet activities. ("Want to send an email AND watch a Youtube video at the same time? You need our Ultra Super Fibernet Max Plus!")
bdcravens 2 hours ago
Yeah I've started seeing Xfinity's billboards for this around town (a growing Houston area suburb), and it's odd to me advertising this as some new development, since I've had AT&T fiber for 4 1/2 years.
kotaKat 2 hours ago
"Powered by fiber" started with Cox, then Charter bought them and adopted it, and then Xfinity latched on and followed along with the "well, HFC is technically fiber!" advertising game.
What I'd really like to know is what the hell is up with the constant begging to sign up for the (Spectrum) mobile service. I've seen free lines for a year being given out like candy (or even wilder, free Internet for business customers that buy 4 lines) and it feels like it's all just to juice the customer into either device payment plans on new equipment or just to look good for the next 4 quarters of mobile subscriber growth and sneak one past the investors.
xp84 2 hours ago
It seems to me like everyone’s trying to bundle everything. Amazon prime wants you to bundle One Medical. Walmart+ bundles Paramount Plus or Peacock and you can now add Sam’s Club to the bundle. T-Mobile wants to bundle every streaming service you have.
Once all of your subscriptions are tangled into two or three big messes, it is extremely unattractive to think about switching any of them. “if I switch my cell service to Verizon, then I’ll have to go screw around trying to undo the combined billing for my Netflix account.” or “if we switch to the new fiber ISP, Spectrum will cancel our cell phones because you have to be a cable subscriber. Gee, I hope that they don’t screw something up and end up losing our phone numbers! Maybe we should just not switch.”
icedchai an hour ago
I'm in Spectrum territory and laugh at the "Fiber-powered Internet" line whenever I see their ads. Technically, yes, it is fiber to the the nearest HFC node, but after that, good luck. There are supposedly a couple of locations where they'll give you actual fiber, but I've never seen one.
Anyway, I switched from cable to actual fiber a few years ago after a year of complaining to the HOA. I was getting massive packet loss and the upstream bandwidth would drop to single digit megabit speeds (they advertised 30.)
arjie 2 hours ago
GFiber (formerly Google Fiber) is also often microwave. We have some of their radios on our apartment building roof.
xp84 2 hours ago
I used to have a local ISP in SF which was microwave. It was excellent. Best ISP I’ve ever had. I loved that it had symmetrical uploads, in fact, my upload was often way higher than my download, I assume just because the downstream channel was more congested. But it was much faster than any other options in both directions.
arjie an hour ago
Monkeybrains or Webpass? Our building has both, Webpass being bought by Google Fiber and now GFiber.
4d4m an hour ago
Monkeybrains is a great ISP
protocolture an hour ago
Its a matter of engineering. The problem isn't the technology, it's that microwave is really low hanging fruit that idiots can halfway engineer. Wireless is basically mud because of shitty sales guys throwing links up and then forcing customers to wear technical debt.
sgarman 2 hours ago
I think they bought webpass and rebranded it?
filoleg an hour ago
If you are talking about Seattle area, that's exactly what they did there.
To be fair, they did well by the original company, and in the region they officially refer to the service as "Google Fiber/Webpass" (or at least they did 3 years ago, before I left the area).
arjie an hour ago
They definitely did that as well. In Austin, I had fiber-to-the-home and here in SF I had them as Microwave. The only FTTH I've had in SF is Sonic, though I've heard some people have AT&T Fiber.
kittikitti 2 hours ago
AT&T also marketed their 4G network as "5GE" which was flagrant false advertising. I don't think corporate really cares, they just want to harm the other corporation. This is just the status quo of telecommunications and tech in America. It's all a scam and marketing, and if you complain, then you're fired.
phoghed an hour ago
Retention guy tried to convince me that Spectrum was “mostly fiber”. Like yeah I’m sure there’s fiber in your network, let me know when it’s touching my house and I’ll switch back.
slow_typist 2 hours ago
PoE, but over fiber. That would be fiber powered.
strbean 40 minutes ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power-over-fiber
There's not really consumer-available stuff, but there is expensive purpose built stuff you can buy for thousands of dollars to send tiny amounts of power.
fc417fc802 an hour ago
That would also be the most terrifyingly dangerous development in power delivery to ever occur.
qurren an hour ago
Bonus, you can plug it into a laser cutter too I guess ?
I worked at Trumpf for a few months, we would shove 10000 watts down a fiber for industrial laser cutters.
xp84 2 hours ago
lol. The only company lazier than Comcast at building FTTP[1] is throwing stones at them. Hilarious! AT&T barely showed up with fiber outside of big buildings when I lived in SF, topping out with 20Mb UVerse as recently as 2017. Now, I live in another area in their footprint and they just aren’t even playing. If you put my address in, in a high-priced suburb, they suggest cellular internet. I’d still be happy to see any big telecom ISP lose a lawsuit like this, because they’re all scum.
[1] edit: I should’ve said “building out infrastructure” since Comcast to be fair doesn’t build any FTTP to speak of, whereas AT&T builds a tiny bit. But if the question is “percentage of your footprint that can access a speed of 1Gbps over the infrastructure you’ve laid to their house” Comcast wins by a (last) mile.
isaacdl an hour ago
For what it’s worth, my mid-sized city in the Midwest has quite a bit of AT&T FTTP and they are expanding at a reasonable pace. I would estimate they cover 80% of the neighborhoods around me (3 years ago, they covered 0%). This is all area previously only serviced by Spectrum coax (asymmetrical DOCSIS).
yasnu5 2 hours ago
When I moved into my current address, the property manager told me I had two options for my ISP: Spectrum or AT&T. Of course as soon as I select AT&T I get a call from one of their sales people telling me "no lol, we aren't actually available there"
So once again, stuck with Spectrum.
excalibur an hour ago
> “Comcast should be required to restore to AT&T any and all profits earned as a result of its false and misleading advertising or provide AT&T with any other restitutionary relief the Court deems appropriate,” the lawsuit said. The lawsuit asked for a permanent injunction “requiring Comcast to cease describing its hybrid fiber-coaxial service as ‘Fiber-Powered.’”
The people Comcast is swindling with their false claims are their own customers, not AT&T. In what universe should this money be refunded to AT&T? It was never theirs! They are not entitled to other people's money!
fc417fc802 an hour ago
If I sell something and someone wins customers away from me by means of false advertising and it's reasonably clear those customers would otherwise have patronized me then I have suffered proportional damages.
wpietri an hour ago
There are two basic attitudes to customers: people vs livestock.
In the former view customers are actual humans, your equals, who have rights and are as deserving of good treatment as you are.
In the latter, customers are your property. Once you have penned them in, you should be able to milk them as you please. They have no rights, and any noise they make to the contrary is so much mooing. Anybody milking customers that are rightfully yours isn't stealing from them. They're stealing from you.
martinald 2 hours ago
I mean Comcast is "fibre powered" from the CMTS onwards.
And DOCSIS4.0 can offer higher speeds than AT&Ts older GPON FTTH.
But regardless it is extremely odd Comcast is spending so much to do a DOCSIS4.0 upgrade, given the costs between that and eg XGSPON are not huge - both require a lot of new equipment and fibre laid.
I am unaware of anyone but Comcast that is adopting DOCSIS4. Afiak all European cable companies are moving to XGS-PON.
illamint 24 minutes ago
I'm on a 2Gbps/2Gbps (but more like 2.5/2.5) DOCSIS4.0 plan in Seattle and as much as I hate to say it, it's been great.
But like, why would they go all the way to XGS-PON when they can use their existing HFC access network, maybe upgrade that to DAA/RPHY, combined with existing subscriber outside plant, and deliver an incremental improvement? As much as I'd love 10Gbps+ service, 2Gbps is already bananas, and there's nothing stopping them from replacing the last mile with glass eventually, either.
xp84 2 hours ago
You said it right there - we’re talking about Comcast here, so obviously if they could save even a nickel by using a technology that’s worse for the customer, they’ll choose that every time. It’s not like they have any competition to worry about! I’m aware AT&T has actual fiber in a few spots, but it’s so sparse compared to the whole footprint that Comcast DGAF if everyone with someone else’s fiber available drops them.
slopnt 2 hours ago
well, it IS fiber-powered (fibers of copper wire)
valleyer 2 hours ago
Both of these companies are doing the same thing. Yes, obviously Comcast is using the word "fiber" to try to piggy-back on the layman's shallow understanding of that word as "fancy Internet thing".
But so is AT&T. The practical limits of optical and DOCSIS are basically equivalent to a home user, but AT&T pitches their product as "fiber" to dazzle the uneducated customer.
In an ideal world, they'd compete just on latency, throughput, and reliability.
jm4 2 hours ago
But AT&T actually runs fiber so I'm not following you here. I have AT&T and it's a real fiber optic cable they ran from the pole into my house. What are you getting at? Meanwhile, Comcast does, in fact, claim they are fiber even though they run coax cable.
pixl97 an hour ago
I have 'cable', but it's actually fiber to my house and there is a power injector in my closet that runs power over the 30' of coax I have to run a coax to fiber converter of some kind. This isn't Comcast, but I suspect lots of new builds have odd things like this. Most people would have no clue what's running to the side of their house.
fc417fc802 an hour ago
crote 2 hours ago
The nutritional values of potatoes and rice are basically equivalent to the average eater. Would it be okay if a "sushi" restaurant stuffed yours with mashed potato instead of rice?
The problem is that Comcast is lying. They are marketing one product (fiber) and delivering another (DOCSIS). That's fraud.
This lawsuit would not exist if Comcast had stuck to a marketing term such as "fiber-like speeds". But they got too greedy, and ended up misleading the consumer.