Europe weakens chemical rules as science links them to 'lifestyle diseases' (lemonde.fr)

133 points by atmosx 5 hours ago

andai 4 hours ago

>Pesticides? According to the WHO-UNEP report, prenatal exposure (as of 2010) to a single family of these products (organophosphates) was, for example, responsible for more than 59,300 cases of intellectual disability per year in European Union (EU) countries. Due to maternal exposure to just this one category of pesticides, a European child born in 2010 lost, on average, about 2.5 IQ points, according to the panel of researchers brought together by WHO and UNEP.

>Still based on population exposure levels in 2010, DDT – a highly persistent insecticide – although banned since the 1970s, was responsible for 56,700 annual cases of uterine fibroids in the EU, 28,200 cases of type 2 diabetes and 1,550 cases of childhood obesity. Even these figures provide only a small glimpse of the situation, as high-quality data are not available for the overwhelming majority of the approximately 400 pesticides registered in Europe.

>When it comes to plasticizers and industrial pollutants, the picture is no different. Exposure (in 2010) to DEHP in Europe caused 145,000 annual cases of endometriosis, 20,500 cases of diabetes and 53,900 cases of obesity. Phthalates in general? They accounted for 618,000 annual cases of male infertility in Europe. Bisphenol A caused 42,400 cases of childhood obesity per year in Europe. And if anyone thinks the press exaggerates the issue of forever chemicals (PFAS, or "per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances"), the WHO-UNEP report reminds us that in the US, where 2018 data allow such an estimate, more than four million cases of obesity are attributable to the two most-studied PFAS, as well as 127,000 annual cases of childhood obesity and 14,000 cases of hypothyroidism.

WillPostForFood 3 hours ago

This is based on a study that didn't directly measures the health effects or economic costs of chemical exposure. It wass a modeling exercise that combines observational studies, animal experiments, exposure estimates, economic assumptions, and opinion. Basically very low quality.

thaumasiotes 3 hours ago

There was a fun observation in American science that the effect of lead on IQ seems to have gotten worse over time.

The postulated mechanism is:

1. Some places have lead, and suck.

2. Because they suck, they are inhabited by people without better options.

3. Those people are stupid.

4. You can do a study comparing the IQs of people in relatively high-lead environments and other people, and, if you attribute the entire difference to lead exposure, you'll see that lead has a negative effect on IQ, which you can represent in terms of IQ points per hair ppm or whatever unit you want.

5. If you then mount a big effort to rehabilitate those environments to clean out the lead, they'll have less lead. Still more than usual, but not as much as before. Lead exposure in the people who live there will fall.

6. But those environments are still bad (if not quite as bad) and the people there are still stupid.

7. If you rerun your study from step 4, you'll observe that people in high-lead areas are still dumber than people in low-lead areas, by about the same amount as the earlier study found.

8. But, the high-lead areas have less lead now than they did then.

9. Attributing the entire IQ deficit to lead exposure, we logically find that each unit of lead exposure is now much more harmful than the earlier study found. There's a lot less lead, but the deficit is just as bad - this means that the effect of the lead got worse!

andai 2 hours ago

PorciiVorbesc 3 hours ago

GrantMoyer 3 hours ago

For a sense of scale, compare to the WHO fact sheet for alcohol use in Europe[1]:

> One in every 11 deaths in the WHO European Region is due to alcohol consumption. About 800,000 deaths a year result from alcohol use in the Region, almost a third of the global total of 2.6 million deaths [from alcohol use].

> In the WHO European Region, more than 1 in every 11 adults experiences alcohol use disorders.

> Alcohol consumption is responsible for 1 in 4 deaths of 19–24-year-olds in the WHO European Region, mainly due to injuries.

I don't bring this up to excuse manufactures of harmful chemicals from producing those harmful chemicals, especially when in some cases there's evidence the manufacturers knew the chemicals were harmful and covered it up. Neither do I want to excuse those manufactures from negligently or intentionally dumping potentially or known harmful chemicals into the environment. I don't excuse regulators from allowing these behaviors either, but I do see where the perspective of "the diseases are mostly caused by peoples own choices" comes from, and how problems like harmful pollution might seem lower priority compared to other issues.

Ultimately though, those view don't hold up. Tackling these sources of public health issues can happen in parallel, and some of these relatively smaller scale issues with well defined causes are certainly easier to address than changing peoples behavior at scale.

[1]: https://www.who.int/europe/news-room/fact-sheets/item/alcoho...

pluralmonad 3 hours ago

The alcohol comparison only makes sense if you don't consider consent. Someone choosing to over consume alcohol is a personal choice. Some pregnant woman soaking in the neighbor corporate ag company's chemicals is a totally different thing.

black_puppydog 2 hours ago

Not sure I understand what "the diseases are mostly caused by peoples own choices" is supposed to apply to here? The mother who's exposed to this because she lives next to a field being sprayed? Or the alcoholics?

someothherguyy 3 hours ago

seems like a problem still. what does it matter if it is based in decision making or not? how is it any different than the choices we are making as a collective group to poison eachother? certainly contributing factors in the causation of alcohol use disorder are an element of those collective choices as well.

stevenomara an hour ago

Alcohol consumption is optional, environmental lead poisoning is not.

dzink 4 hours ago

Europe restricts local farmers and industry from using these then proceeds to import much cheaper food from countries that have no such restrictions.

vladms 4 hours ago

The problem is that currently probably nobody can provide food that is cheap, good, healthy and available all year around.

Then what are the options? Force people to eat healthy and expensive? Allow everybody to produce cheap and unhealthy? The current situation seems like a compromise: whoever cares and can afford will buy European stuff (more expensive, probably more healthy); who can't afford can still buy cheap stuff.

Ideally, I would like stricter controls at the border, to eliminate some of the worst offenders. But even ignoring that, allowing lots of new pesticides in European soil (not that fields are not probably full of stuff already) will have direct cost on health care in the years to come.

drdexebtjl 3 hours ago

>available all year around

Since when did this become a standard? For our entire history, food was not available all year around. We ate seasonal food and preserved food for later. We mostly ate things that could be grown locally. Everything else was luxury.

vladms an hour ago

WalterBright 2 hours ago

TeMPOraL 2 hours ago

> Then what are the options?

Expensive and perhaps limited import licenses, to force the everyday diet to come from locally grown crops and be seasonal. Prices for staples will stay low because market is a dynamic system so locally grown supply will quickly increase once it doesn't need to compete with cheap imports. Then the govts will have any chance of controlling methods and chemicals used in agriculture, too.

tancop an hour ago

Genetic engineering, or keeping pests away with a physical barrier. You might still need pesticides but only in places that have an actual infestation.

But I think a secure supply of cheap food is more important than preventing a minor health risk. And I would support engineering humans to tolerate these things better.

GrantMoyer 3 hours ago

> The problem is that currently probably nobody can provide food that is cheap, good, healthy and available all year around.

We can, but we feed it to livestock instead of humans. Obviously, we'd want some improvement in quality control for human grade food, but the capacity is there.

pluralmonad 3 hours ago

Asmod4n 3 hours ago

You can just move subsidies from corn to protein based food. Agriculture eats around 33% of all payed subsidies and 33% of that goes to corn.

The food pyramid everyone gets shown at school is reversed to how it should be.

primroot 2 hours ago

Shitty-kitty 2 hours ago

mrguyorama an hour ago

rrr_oh_man 3 hours ago

rgblambda 2 hours ago

mullingitover 2 hours ago

seizethecheese 3 hours ago

If you remove “cheap” can you have “good, healthy and available year round”? Obviously making food way more expensive would be terrible for most of the world, but for the rich world it seems like cheap food is just paid for in healthcare costs.

dragontamer 3 hours ago

petre 3 hours ago

> Then what are the options?

Bugs, obviously. But then the right wing wackos and the Dutch famers party that are pesticide addicts will start screaming that the EU makes us eat bugs.

mapcars 3 hours ago

zappb an hour ago

PorciiVorbesc 3 hours ago

otherme123 3 hours ago

You implying that Europe allow the importing of anything, and that is not true. People from other countries need to also have minimum standards to be able to sell in the UE. And they of course need to comply with the same standards than UE producers to stamp tags like "bio", "eco" or "fair trade".

A clear example: eggs from the US (cleaned) cannot be imported to the UE, and viceversa.

https://food.ec.europa.eu/horizontal-topics/official-control...

supermatt 2 hours ago

Sure, but those minimum standards differ. For example, in the EU certain pesticides are outright banned, but those same pesticide made foods are permitted for import if they are below certain non-zero levels. We also have very strict animal welfare standards, which do not apply to imported meat products.

otherme123 16 minutes ago

guywithahat 3 hours ago

Eggs are a very famous example where the US and EU independently decided to have diametrically opposed standards for egg safety, and so they can’t be exported to each other.

Most foods have a more board set of safety requirements, and won’t face the same high level of scrutiny as locally produced food.

skywal_l 4 hours ago

Because The EU is torn between the greens on one side and the neo-liberals on the other. The association of the two really looks like a conspiracy to destroy the EU.

rbehrends an hour ago

No, it is simply in the treaties. For example, Article 191 TFEU [1] encodes preserving the environment, protecting human health, and the precautionary principle.

The free (and social!) market economy is set out as a principle in Article 3 (3) [2] TEU and Articles 119 and 120 TFEU [3].

These do not exist in the treaties because the EU is torn between two wings; they (along with other provisions) largely exist because they were prerequisites for the member states to agree to give the EU legislative power by ensuring there were safeguards in place to limit that power.

[1] https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Consolidated_version_of_the_T...

[2] https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Consolidated_version_of_the_T...

[3] https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Consolidated_version_of_the_T...

lyu07282 an hour ago

The green parties were always neoliberals too, their argument was always some version of saving the environment while also stimulating the economy. This is what Greta Thurnberg evolved away from and why today she makes fun of these environmentalist groups she was once a part of after recognizing how they are all just more neoliberals that will never actually do anything to address climate catastrophe.

mmooss an hour ago

> The EU is torn between the greens on one side and the neo-liberals on the other.

That omits the populist right, possibly the leading force in Europe.

wk_end 4 hours ago

One side represents "the better angels of our nature", the other side represents (charitably) the need to actually get people fed, prosperity, or (less charitably) the enduring popularity of cheap shit.

It's no conspiracy; it's the natural consequence of a democracy of man accurately reflecting the duality of man.

spwa4 4 hours ago

contravariant 4 hours ago

233mhz 4 hours ago

Same with co2, regulate everything locally so we can't produce them anymore, then import them from god knows where. The co2 output is the same...

nullc 3 hours ago

> the co2 output is the same...

no the transport makes it worse as does the coal fired industry rather than being powered by 50% solar.

tonyedgecombe 4 hours ago

This is a common talking point but it doesn’t hold much water. Imports represent a relatively small percentage of emissions. Most co2 output comes from buildings and transport.

233mhz 2 hours ago

adamddev1 an hour ago

What about vinyl flooring? The FDA is doing a long investigation on a key ingredient, and the EU has already placed PVC on a "restriction roadmap." It gives some people headaches and other symptoms. But sadly it keeps getting installed in houses more and more.

https://europe.noharm.org/news/eu-has-legal-duty-ban-pvc-ngo...

andai 4 hours ago

AIShill101 3 hours ago

Thnx

andrewclunn 4 hours ago

I think the notion that agriculture and industry are two separate categories is a relic that doesn't really hold in the 21st century (and honestly for part of the previous one as well). The small scale "family farm" is almost non-existent now. If true factory farming is going to be the standard, then they should be seen as similar to any other factory, and pregnant women and young children should stay away for fear of the resulting impacts on development.

motbus3 2 hours ago

Make life expensive. Them blame people for not buying healthy food

PowerElectronix 3 hours ago

EU is a sham. Regulations that cost europe entire industries and results that amount to barely virtue signaling about wanting a better world.

fcarraldo 3 hours ago

I don’t understand this post. The article describes the EU weakening regulations in order to relax the burden on industries. It also describes that scientific consensus has strengthened since the regulations were put in place, and the consensus is that these chemicals are harmful to the population.

The takeaway is supposed to be that the EU’s regulation schemes are working (for the people) but are being dismantled due to right wing politics and industry pressure.

How did you get nearly the opposite?

patrickmcnamara 3 hours ago

You're not gonna find people being rational about the EU on HN.

LorenPechtel an hour ago

And where does this article say it's a scientific consensus? It's one report.

oulipo 3 hours ago

EU is one of the biggest commercial power today. It's also a (relative) beacon of dialog, diversity and democracy compared to the sorry state of the rest of the world.

croes 3 hours ago

It’s really a shame that companies in the EU can’t give a crap about people like in China and the US.

More sick and death people would also mean more profit for pharmaceutical companies and less unemployment.

A win-win

Sharlin 4 hours ago

Can't be "competitive" in this world without being prepared to break a few eggs. Or that's what the neoliberals claim.

kleiba2 4 hours ago

> If you are ill, [...] it is because you did not lead your life properly. [...] And if not, perhaps the problem lies in your DNA, or you were simply unlucky.

We're off to a good start, Cpt. Obvious!

PorciiVorbesc 3 hours ago

I think the author meant it sarcastically. It helps if you read the entire paragraph from start to finish, you get a feel of the tone. I think the author does a good job of being subtle that some people miss it on the first read.

KolmogorovComp 3 hours ago

not detecting sarcasm makes you the Cpt. Obvious. Reading past the first sentence may have helped you understand it.

londons_explore 3 hours ago

> a European child born in 2010 lost, on average, about 2.5 IQ points,

I suspect a loss of 2.5 IQ points is enough to tank an economy. Any data to confirm or refute my hypothesis?

maxerickson 2 hours ago

US lead exposure estimates are higher than that, peaking in the 60s.

I guess if you think economy bad or not you can use that evidence either way. Realistically, there has been enormous growth in the US economy in the last 30,40,50 years.

kube-system an hour ago

I suspect in the scheme of things, average IQ of a population has very little to do with overall economic output or growth.

Squarex 3 hours ago

I wonder how they meassured it. There are plenty of other explanations for IQ loss.

dgellow 3 hours ago

Aren’t you expected to be the one coming up with something to back your hypothesis?

Jerrrrrrrrry 2 hours ago

Statistics like those are basically illegal in europe now.

Lazy euro fed bait

coryrc 2 hours ago

Trump voters and the economy now.